Cognitive and behavioural models
The cognitive model, the three levels of thinking, the learning principles behind behaviour therapy, how a CBT formulation is built with the client, and how CBT is done in a structured, time-limited and collaborative way, with work between sessions.
Quick check
Answer each one in your own words, then open the model answer to compare. Signed in, your answers are kept and marked, and the plan uses them.
1.A 41-year-old accountant works eighty-hour weeks and checks every figure three times. She has never made an error, but she is exhausted, and she says that if she stopped checking, everyone would find out she is no good at her job. In the third session, after the psychologist and client have started a draft formulation, the psychologist considers asking her to cut back the checking from next week. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to ask her to cut back the checking from next week, or first to add the checking and the belief it protects to the draft formulation with her and then reduce the checking as a planned experiment, and the second is better. The checking is a compensatory strategy that protects a core belief of incompetence, and because nothing is left unchecked the belief is never tested. If the checking is cut before she understands its part in the pattern, she is likely to become anxious and go back to it. Once she sees how the checking protects the belief, the psychologist should set up reduced checking as a behavioural experiment to test her prediction that an error will be found and she will be shown to be incompetent.
2.A 34-year-old office worker was stuck in a lift for two hours. Since then he has taken the stairs to his tenth-floor office, and he now avoids trains and crowded shops. His manager has offered him a desk on the ground floor, and the client asks the psychologist whether he should take it. What should the psychologist advise?
Model answer
The options are to advise him to take the ground-floor desk so that his distress settles, to advise him to take the desk and start graded exposure as well, or to advise him to keep his current desk and start graded exposure, and the third is the better advice. The fear probably began through classical conditioning and has generalised from lifts to other enclosed and crowded places. Each time he avoids one of these places, the relief negatively reinforces the avoidance, so the fear does not fade. Moving desks, even alongside exposure, would be one more avoidance, so the psychologist should explain this, plan graded exposure that starts with short lift rides he can manage, and respect his decision if he still chooses to move.
3.In the second session a 36-year-old man with low mood since a redundancy says, "You're the expert, just tell me what's wrong with me and what to do." The psychologist's working diagnosis is major depressive disorder, and the psychologist has a formulation in mind. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to give him the diagnosis and the formulation as an expert opinion, as he has asked, or to share the diagnosis and then build the formulation with him, and the second is right. A diagnosis names the problem, but the formulation is a set of hypotheses about why the problem developed and what keeps it going, so the psychologist should draft it with him and ask whether each part fits. Checking each hypothesis with the client in this way is called collaborative empiricism. The psychologist can meet his wish for expert input by explaining the model, and his corrections are likely to improve the draft.
4.A 38-year-old teacher says: "The principal walked past without saying hello. She's obviously unhappy with my work. If a boss is unhappy with you, you're finished. I've never been good enough at anything." The teacher asks to go straight to what she calls the real problem, her belief that she has never been good enough. Where should the psychologist start the cognitive work?
Model answer
The options are to start with the core belief, as she asks, or with the assumption, "If a boss is unhappy with you, you're finished", or with the automatic thought, "She's obviously unhappy with my work". The automatic thought is the better start, because it is the easiest of the three to catch and to test, and the skills she learns there make the later work on the assumption and the belief easier. The thought is mind reading, because she believes she knows what the principal thinks without considering other possibilities, such as that the principal was in a hurry. The psychologist should explain this order to her and move to the assumption and then to the core belief as she gains the skill.
5.A 29-year-old woman with social anxiety is sure that if she speaks in a meeting, her colleagues will think she is stupid. She asks to leave out the exposure tasks and "just do the thinking work", because the tasks make her too anxious. The psychologist is worried that the client will drop out if the tasks stay in the plan. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to drop the exposure to keep her engaged, to put it off until she feels ready, or to keep exposure in the plan and lead into it from the work on her prediction, and the third is right. Her prediction that her colleagues will think she is stupid can be tested most directly when she enters the feared situations, so the thinking work should lead into exposure rather than replace it. Dropping the tasks, or putting them off until she feels ready, is the same avoidance that maintains her fear. The psychologist should go back to the rationale for exposure with her and agree a small first step she can manage.