Humanistic, narrative and solution-focused models
The person-centred conditions, narrative therapy including with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander clients, and solution-focused brief therapy.
Quick check
Answer each one in your own words, then open the model answer to compare. Signed in, your answers are kept and marked, and the plan uses them.
1.A psychologist working narratively with a 28-year-old woman has been writing letters to her after sessions, using her own words. Over three months she has returned to part-time work. Her GP asks for a summary of her diagnosis and treatment plan, and the woman agrees to the psychologist sending one. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to send a summary of the diagnosis and plan straight away, to send one of her session letters with the summary so the GP can see her progress, or to go through with her what the summary will say before sending it, and the third is right. Before information is disclosed, a client should know what will be disclosed and why, so the psychologist should go through the summary with her rather than send it straight away. When the psychologist goes through it with her, she can also have a say in how her progress, such as her return to work, is described. A session letter was written for her rather than for the GP, so sending one would share more than she agreed to.
2.A 42-year-old man referred for his drinking says in the first session that "the drink" takes him over and that it is not really him who shouts at his children. The psychologist works narratively. How should the psychologist respond to the way he describes the drinking?
Model answer
The options are to accept his account that it is the drink that shouts, to externalise the drinking while holding him responsible for the shouting, or to tell him outright that the drinking and the shouting are his responsibility, and the second is right. The drinking can be talked about as a problem outside him, but the shouting is something he does to his children, so he stays responsible for it. Telling him outright is likely to damage the alliance before the work has begun. The psychologist must also ask what the shouting has cost his children and whether they are safe.
3.In a fourth session, a 50-year-old man says, "You keep nodding and saying you understand, but you don't." The psychologist feels stung. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to reassure him that the psychologist does understand, to explain what the psychologist meant, or to accept his comment as accurate and ask what the psychologist has missed, and the third is right. Empathy is thought to help only when the client perceives it, so his experience is what counts. Reassuring or explaining would defend the psychologist's own view, and would respond from the psychologist's frame of reference rather than his. Acknowledging the misunderstanding, taking responsibility for it and asking him to say more also shows genuineness, because the psychologist is not pretending to have understood.
4.In a third session of solution-focused work, a 45-year-old woman who rated her progress towards her goal at 3 out of 10 last week says she is now at 2 after an argument with her sister. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to explore in detail what has made things worse, to reassure her that setbacks are a normal part of change, or to ask what has kept her from falling lower, and the third is right. In SFBT, after a setback the psychologist would usually ask what the client did to avoid falling to the bottom of the scale, because the answer shows coping she can build on. Exploring what made things worse would move the session back into talk about the problem, and reassuring her would give the psychologist's view rather than draw on her experience. If she also describes hopelessness or thoughts of death, the psychologist should assess risk first.
5.A 47-year-old woman is referred through her workplace's employee assistance program after complaints about her conduct at work. She tells the psychologist that her manager is the problem and that he needs to change. The psychologist works in a solution-focused way. What should the psychologist do?
Model answer
The options are to acknowledge her view and ask what would be different for her if things at work were better, to treat her as a visitor and use a scaling question to gauge how much she wants anything to change, or to set the goal about her conduct that the referrer wants, and the first is right. She agrees there is a problem but believes the solution is for her manager to change, so in SFBT this is a complainant relationship rather than a visitor one. Treating her as a visitor would miss that she has named a problem she wants solved, and setting the referrer's goal would ignore her as the expert on what will help. Asking what would be different for her can lead to a goal of her own.